Est. 2025

Practical writing on work, money, home and life

Better Writing SkillsBetter Writing Skills.

Where good writers get read

How to Choose a Phone Without Paying for Features You Will Not Use

A guide for a commuter with about £400 to spend, covering update promises, battery life, repairability, storage and the real cost of a phone deal, with EU and UK sources.

New smartphone sitting in its open retail box

You’re a commuter with a cracked three-year-old phone and about £400 to spend, and every shop window says the newest model is the one you need. To buy a phone without overpaying, decide how many years you’ll keep it first, then pay for the things that matter over that time: software updates, a battery you can replace, a screen that survives a drop, and a deal that costs what it says. Camera megapixels and the processor name come well down the list.

This is general consumer information, not personal financial advice. Prices, contract rules and rights differ by country and change often. The regulations below are from the EU and the UK, and the article says which is which.

Buy a phone without overpaying: start with how long you’ll keep it

The cheapest phone is usually the one you keep for the longest time, so the useful number is cost per year, not the price on the label. Example (illustrative prices): a £450 phone kept for five years costs £90 a year. A £900 phone kept for three years costs £300 a year. The second may be a better phone, but you’d need to be getting £210 a year of extra value from it.

That sum only works if the phone stays safe and usable. This is where software support comes in.

Software updates: the figure to look for

The European Commission says new ecodesign rules for smartphones and tablets have applied since 20 June 2025. Its announcement says operating system updates must be available for at least 5 years from the date the last unit of the model is sold. The Commission’s product page words it as at least 5 years from the end of placement on the market of the last unit of a product model.

The counting matters. Five years from the last unit sold is longer than five years from launch, so an older model that’s still on sale gets a longer tail than the number suggests. If you buy a model that has already been out for two years, work out how many years of updates actually remain.

In the UK, GOV.UK’s guidance on consumer connectable product security lists “publishing information on minimum security update periods” among the security requirements, and says the regulations came into effect on 29 April 2024. Whether a particular product is in scope is for the maker to confirm, so ask the seller for the end date of security updates for the exact model, and look for it on the product page.

The most useful line on a phone’s spec sheet is the date security updates stop.

Battery: what to check and what to ask

The same EU rules require phone batteries to withstand at least 800 charge and discharge cycles while keeping at least 80% of their original capacity, according to the Commission’s product page.

Example: if you drain and recharge roughly once a day, 800 cycles is a little over two years of daily use, after which the battery can still hold 80% of its original capacity. That’s not a failure point. It’s a floor that makers must meet, and many phones will do better. Check whether the label or spec sheet shows the cycle figure, and compare phones on it.

Ask two further questions in the shop. Can the battery be replaced by an independent repairer, and does the maker offer a replacement service with a listed price? A battery swap in year three can add years to a phone’s life, so find out the price before you buy.

Repairability and durability: the label helps

The Commission’s announcement says the EU energy label for smartphones and tablets shows energy efficiency, battery lifespan and resistance to dust, water and drops, along with a repairability score from A (most repairable) to E (least repairable). It describes this as the first time a product on the EU market must display a repairability score. The product page adds that drop resistance is also rated from A to E.

The rules also oblige manufacturers to supply key spare parts within 5 to 10 working days, and to keep them available for at least 7 years after the model is no longer sold in the EU. Outside the EU you won’t see this label on every phone, but the same questions work as a benchmark: how long are parts sold for, and can anyone repair it?

What to checkWhere to find itWhat a good answer looks like
Years of OS and security updatesMaker’s support page; EU label or UK product pageAn end date that covers the years you plan to keep it
Battery enduranceEU label (cycles); spec sheetAt least 800 cycles to 80%, with a listed replacement price
Repairability classEU label (A to E)The highest class you can afford; parts sold for years
Drop, dust and water ratingsEU label; IP ratingMatches how you actually treat the phone
StorageYour current phone’s settingsYour current use plus room to grow
Total costThe contract or receiptPhone, plan, case and repair costs added up

Storage and camera: where people pay for too much

Storage

Open your current phone’s storage settings and note how much you use, then add room for the next few years of apps and photos. If you back up photos to a cloud service, a smaller size may be enough, but remember the cloud service may charge monthly. Example: if you use 70 GB now and add about 15 GB a year, five years takes you to about 145 GB, so a 128 GB phone would be tight and a 256 GB one comfortable. Compare the price gap between sizes with a year or two of a cloud plan before you decide.

Camera

Megapixel counts on their own tell you little. The camera test that matters is the one you can do yourself: take photos indoors in the evening, of a moving child or pet, and of text on a page, then zoom in on the screen. Take the same set of shots on each phone you’re considering and compare them on a laptop screen. As practical advice rather than a tested claim, mid-range phones often look close to flagships in daylight, and the differences tend to show in low light and video, so test those.

The real cost: contract versus buying outright

A monthly deal can hide what you’re paying for the handset. Ofcom, the UK regulator, says in its guide to telecoms price rises that providers must set out price rises clearly, in pounds and pence, before you sign up, and must say when any changes to your monthly price will take place. The page says providers have been banned from offering new contracts with inflation-linked price rises since January 2025, and that contracts signed before 17 January 2025 might still include price rises.

The same Ofcom page says that if your contract doesn’t say how much the price can rise, or the provider raises it by more than the contract states, the provider must tell you at least 30 days before the increase takes effect and give you 30 days to leave without paying exit fees. Read the pricing section of the contract for those pounds-and-pence figures before you sign.

Example (illustrative prices): a contract at £28 a month for 36 months costs £1,008. A SIM-only plan at £10 a month for 36 months costs £360, and a phone bought outright for £400 brings the total to £760. The difference is £248 over three years. The contract may still make sense if it includes things you’d pay for anyway, but add them up before you decide.

Add the extras

Add a case and screen protector (say £20 to £40), and any insurance. Compare insurance with what your household or bank account already covers, and check the excess you’d pay on a claim.

Buy last year’s model

When a new model launches, the previous one is often cheaper and still does nearly everything the new one does. The catch is the update clock above: an older model may have fewer years of support left, so check the end date before you buy. Refurbished phones can also save money. Ask for the warranty length in writing, whether the battery has been replaced, and what the return window is.

A buying plan you can follow in an evening

  1. Decide how many years you want the phone to last, and write the number down.
  2. Check how much storage you use now, and how fast it grows.
  3. Shortlist three phones and find the security update end date for each.
  4. Compare their battery cycle figures, repairability class and replacement battery price.
  5. Try each in a shop: hold it, take photos indoors, check the screen outdoors.
  6. Price each option two ways, outright with SIM-only and on a contract, over the full period.
  7. Add a case, protection and insurance, then divide the total by the years you expect to keep it.

Your checklist before paying

  • Security updates are promised until a date that covers your plan
  • Battery endurance and replacement price are known
  • Repairability class or repair options are known
  • Storage covers your current use plus a margin
  • The monthly price and any rises are written in pounds and pence
  • The phone works on any network, or you know the date it stops being tied to one
  • Case, protection and insurance costs are included
  • Return window and warranty are in writing

Common mistakes

Paying for a flagship camera you’ll never push is the most common one. Spend that money on storage, battery or a longer update window instead.

The second is comparing monthly prices instead of totals. A phone on a 36-month deal can look cheap each month and cost more than buying the phone and a SIM-only plan separately.

The third is ignoring repair costs until the screen breaks. Check what a screen and a battery cost before you buy, not after.

The takeaway

Pick the phone that will be supported and repairable for as long as you plan to keep it, then price the whole deal, not just the monthly figure. Ask for the security update end date, the battery figure and the repair costs in writing, and let those numbers decide, not the newest launch.

Editorial Team Avatar

About the author

The Sunday Letter

One useful read, every Sunday.

A short note from the editors with the week’s most practical article. No hype, no daily blasts.

Sign-ups are handled through our contact page for now.